Carniceria Guanajuato
If you're looking for authentic Mexican flavors in the heart of Indianapolis, then Carniceria Guanajuato is a hidden gem you absolutely need to try. Located at 1269 Oliver Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46221, this restaurant has been a local favorite for food lovers who crave fresh, flavorful, and high-quality Mexican cuisine. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or planning a special meal, Carniceria Guanajuato offers a dining experience that brings the rich culinary traditions of Guanajuato, Mexico, straight to your table.
Authentic Mexican Flavors You Can’t Miss
One of the key features that sets Carniceria Guanajuato apart from other restaurants in the area is its commitment to serving authentic, traditional Mexican food. The name "Carniceria" itself is a nod to the Mexican butchery tradition, and the restaurant is proud to offer fresh cuts of meat for both its in-house dishes and take-home options. From tender carnitas to flavorful steaks, the meats are always of the highest quality, cooked to perfection with expert seasoning and care.
Not only is the food made with premium ingredients, but the flavors are also deeply rooted in the culinary traditions of Guanajuato. Dishes like Tacos al Pastor, Birria, and Barbacoa transport diners to Mexico, offering bold, savory flavors with every bite. Whether you're a fan of sizzling fajitas or enjoying a classic taco de carne asada, the experience at Carniceria Guanajuato will leave you craving more.
A Unique Experience for Every Visit
When you step inside Carniceria Guanajuato, you’re not just visiting a restaurant—you’re embarking on a cultural journey. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, with vibrant décor that reflects the rich heritage of Guanajuato. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and passionate about the food they serve, always eager to share recommendations and provide a personalized dining experience.
The menu features a wide variety of options, ensuring that every guest can find something to enjoy. From street-style tacos and burritos to hearty platters and sizzling fajitas, there’s something to satisfy every craving. Be sure to try the restaurant’s signature dish, Tacos al Pastor, marinated with a blend of spices and served with fresh pineapple—a combination that hits all the right notes.
For those who prefer to enjoy the flavors of Carniceria Guanajuato at home, the restaurant also offers a butcher section where you can pick up fresh cuts of meat, salsas, and other Mexican staples. This allows you to recreate your favorite dishes at home or bring a piece of the restaurant’s flavor into your kitchen.
Carniceria Guanajuato’s Commitment to Quality and Freshness
One of the restaurant's core principles is its dedication to quality and freshness. Unlike many chain restaurants that rely on pre-packaged ingredients, Carniceria Guanajuato sources only the finest meats and vegetables for its dishes. The result is a menu filled with bold, fresh flavors that are hard to find elsewhere in Indianapolis.
The restaurant's focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients extends beyond the meat to include a range of house-made salsas, guacamole, and tortillas. Everything is prepared with care, ensuring that each meal is not only delicious but also a true reflection of Mexican culinary traditions.
Reviews
Half restaurant, half grocery store. Impeccable service. There's this cool statue that is right when you walk in. Standard Mexican grub that's always really good. If you want a lot of food do the Surf and Turf. Last time I did Cubano torta...ridiculously big and really good. A solid member of my monthly work lunch rotation.
Great hidden gem! Large portions with authentic Mexican food at very affordable prices. Visit the attached grocery store and the vast meat department for some additional opportunities to take something home. Menu in Spanish and English.
If you are in downtown Indy and are looking for the best Mexican restaurant, look no further. It's not quite walking distance from downtown, but if you have access to a vehicle, it's only 5 minutes away. The restaurant is fairly new and connected to the grocery store. (The grocery store used to have a taqueria inside, but it got so popular that they bought the space next door and opened a full service restaurant. There is still a little taqueria in the grocery store, but the menu is extremely limited now.)
Great Mexican grocery store they have a variety of stuff. It's a pretty big store though not as big as the one in Lafayette Rd. Customer service was great and place was clean and neat as will. Moreover if you're coming for some meat/chicken be sure to come early because the line will be extremely long. I think I waited for like 20-30 minutes to be helped. Also you do have to get a number because they go by number. Furthermore I really recommend this grocery store.
I was fully expecting a small hole in the wall restaurant, however I was pleasantly surprised to see a spacious and beautiful restaurant. We came specifically to try the tacos as they've created the reputation of being very inexpensive and authentic tacos. They don't have prices on the menu however I believe they were 2-3 dollars per taco however they tasted like they were 10 dollars each. The service was amazing and our tacos came out within 5 minutes. The fish tacos had great potential however the only flaw was that they were very dry. The Al pastor tacos were a nice change to the fish tacos as they were more savory and juicy. The meat was fantastic and it really nailed the salty-sweet combination. The quality is there and it really puts bang for your buck to another level. The server even gave us a free to go cup of salsa and bag of chips which was incredibly generous.